How to start a movie club with friends

Pick a format, keep the group small, choose films with a simple rule and talk about them well. A step-by-step guide to starting a movie club that lasts.

Rows of empty black cinema seats in a dark room

A movie club is a book club for films: a small group watches the same film, then gets together to talk about it. To start one, decide whether you'll watch together or apart, invite six to ten people, set a regular night, and agree on a simple way to pick the next film. The rest of this guide covers each step and what to talk about once the credits roll.

1. Choose your format

There are two kinds of movie club, and each works.

  • Watch together. Everyone comes over, you watch the film, then talk. It's an evening out of one film, and nobody has to find time on their own.
  • Watch apart, meet to talk. Everyone watches the film during the week, wherever and however they like, then the group meets for an hour to discuss it. It suits long films, busy schedules and friends in different cities.

Many clubs start with watch-together nights and switch to watching apart once the group grows or the films get longer. Either way, decide up front so people know what they're signing up for.

A glass bowl full of popcorn

2. Keep the group small

Six to ten people is enough for a lively talk and small enough that everyone gets a word in. For watch-together nights, the size of your sofa sets the limit. For online clubs, a video call stays comfortable up to about eight voices.

Invite people with different tastes. A club where everyone loves the same three directors runs out of things to argue about.

3. Set a rhythm

Once a month is a good start for a watch-apart club. Every other week works for a watch-together club that's mostly a social night. Fix the slot, such as the first Friday of the month, and set the next date before everyone leaves.

4. Pick films with a simple rule

How you choose matters more than what you choose. Some rules that work:

  • Rotate the picker. Each meeting, a different person chooses. They introduce the film in a sentence or two next time and lead the talk.
  • Themes. A month of one director, one decade, one country, or films that share a subject. Themes give the discussion something to compare.
  • Pairings. A film and its remake, a book and its adaptation, or a classic and the newer film it inspired.
  • Work through a list. Critics' polls make a ready-made syllabus. In Sight and Sound's 2022 poll of the greatest films of all time, 1,639 critics, programmers, curators, archivists and academics voted, and Chantal Akerman's Jeanne Dielman, 23 quai du Commerce, 1080 Bruxelles (1975) came out on top. A club could spend years on that list.

Check where each film is streaming, for rent or at the library before you lock it in, so nobody gets stuck.

5. Screen it the right way

Watching a film at home with your friends is fine. Showing one in public is different. Under US copyright law, a performance counts as public when it happens at a place open to the public or anywhere a substantial number of people beyond a normal circle of family and friends gather. If your club grows into screenings at a café, library or community hall, that's a public performance, and the venue or the club needs a license to show the film. Venues that host screenings often already have one, so ask them first.

6. Talk about the film

A good discussion starts broad and gets specific. Start with a round: everyone rates the film out of five and says why in one sentence. Then pick a few of these:

  1. What's the first image that comes to mind when you think of the film?
  2. Which scene would you show someone to convince them to watch it?
  3. Did the film earn its ending?
  4. Which character did you understand best, and which least?
  5. What did the music or sound do that you only noticed afterward?
  6. How did the camera make you feel about a character?
  7. Was there a moment that felt too long, or one that ended too soon?
  8. What does the title mean once you've seen the film?
  9. How would this film be different if it were made today?
  10. If you could change one decision the director made, what would it be?
  11. Which other film does this one remind you of?
  12. Would you watch it again? What would you look for the second time?

Let the host keep things moving and draw in the quieter members. The best nights usually come from a disagreement, so don't rush past one.

7. Keep it going between meetings

  • Share ratings and a line as you watch. It gives the next meeting a starting point and keeps people who missed a night in the loop.
  • Agree on spoilers. Until the meeting, no talking about the ending in the group chat.
  • Keep a list of the films you've watched. Looking back over a year of picks at the end of December is half the fun.
A Movie Club card on an iPhone lock screen: a friend gives Weapons four stars and calls it the creepiest hallway shot in years
A friend's rating and one line, shared after they watch.

Frequently asked questions

What's the difference between a movie club and a film club?

Nothing official. "Film club" or "film society" often means a club that holds public screenings, and "movie club" is more often a group of friends. The steps are the same, except that public screenings need a license.

How often should a movie club meet?

Monthly for clubs that watch on their own and meet to talk. Every week or two for clubs that watch together, since the meeting is the viewing.

How do you run an online movie club?

Pick the film a week ahead, let everyone watch on their own schedule, and meet on a video call to talk. Keep the call to about an hour and use the same questions you'd use in person.

How do you choose the first film?

Pick something most people haven't seen, that's easy to find and under two hours. A first meeting goes better with a film that splits the room a little than with one everyone already loves.

Start Movie Club

Log the films you watch, get the inside track, and see what your friends thought.

Open in App Store

Psst is invite-only. Sign up with code MOVIECLUB

Scan with your iPhone / Download Psst

Psst is invite-only. Sign up with code MOVIECLUB

Sources

  1. 17 U.S. Code § 101 - Definitions
  2. Revealed: the results of the 2022 Sight and Sound Greatest Films of All Time poll
  3. The Greatest Films of All Time