Book club discussion questions: 60 that work for any book

Sixty book club discussion questions for any book, grouped by first reactions, characters, story, writing, themes and the ending, plus how to use them well.

A hand turning the pages of an open paperback

The best book club questions are open, specific to what you just read, and impossible to answer with yes or no. The 60 below work for almost any novel and most nonfiction. Pick six to eight before the meeting, start with an easy one, and let the best answer lead the conversation.

How to use these questions

  • Choose a handful, not all of them. Six to eight questions fill a 90-minute meeting. Any more and you end up rushing past the good ones.
  • Open with a round. Ask everyone to rate the book out of five in one sentence. It warms up the quiet people and shows you where the group disagrees.
  • Follow the energy. When a question starts a real argument, stay there. The list is a backup for when the room goes quiet.
  • Mix the kinds. One or two about characters, one about the writing, one about the ending, and one that asks people about their own lives makes for a balanced night.
  • Share them ahead of time if your group likes to prepare. Some readers enjoy noting answers as they read. Others prefer to be surprised. Ask your group which they want.

First reactions

  1. What was your first reaction when you finished the book?
  2. Did the book live up to what you expected from the cover or the title?
  3. Which part did you read fastest, and where did you slow down?
  4. Was there a moment you almost stopped reading? What kept you going?
  5. If you had to describe the book in three words, which would you choose?
  6. Who would you recommend this book to, and who would you warn away?
  7. What's one question you still have after finishing?
  8. Did the book feel like it was written for someone like you?

Characters

  1. Which character did you understand best, and which one least?
  2. Who would you most like to have dinner with, and who would you avoid?
  3. Did any character change in a way that surprised you?
  4. Which character's choices frustrated you, and did you understand them by the end?
  5. Did you trust the narrator? Why or why not?
  6. Which minor character deserved more pages?
  7. How did the main character's past shape the decisions they made?
  8. If one character had acted differently, how would the story have changed?
  9. Which relationship in the book felt most true to life?
  10. Did your opinion of anyone shift between the first and last chapters?

The story

  1. What did you think the book was going to be about after the first chapter?
  2. Which scene stays with you most, and why?
  3. Did the pacing work for you, or did parts drag?
  4. Were there plot turns you saw coming? Which ones caught you off guard?
  5. How did the setting, the place and the time, shape what happened?
  6. What role did luck or chance play in the story?
  7. Was there a subplot you would have cut?
  8. If the book had a sequel, what would you want it to follow?
A stack of books on a wooden desk under a reading lamp

The writing

  1. Was there a line or passage you read twice or marked?
  2. How would you describe the author's voice to someone who hasn't read the book?
  3. Did the structure, such as shifting narrators, letters or jumps in time, help or get in the way?
  4. How did the author build tension?
  5. What did the title mean to you once you'd finished?
  6. Did the dialogue sound like real people talking?
  7. What would you cut if you were the editor?
  8. If this became a film or a series, what would be hardest to adapt?

Themes and ideas

  1. What do you think the book is really about, underneath the plot?
  2. Which idea in the book do you agree with most, and which do you push back on?
  3. Did the book change how you think about anything?
  4. How does the book treat power, and who has it?
  5. What does the book say about family?
  6. Does the book feel connected to anything happening in the world right now?
  7. Which symbols or repeated images did you notice?
  8. Did the book make an argument, or did it leave you to decide?

The ending

  1. Did the ending feel earned?
  2. Was the ending the one you wanted? If not, what would you have written?
  3. Which loose ends did the author leave open, and was that a good choice?
  4. How did the last chapter change the way you see the first?
  5. Where do you imagine the main character is five years later?
  6. Did the ending make you want to reread the book?

You and the book

  1. Did any part of the book remind you of something in your own life?
  2. Which character are you most like, honestly?
  3. Would you have made the same choice as the main character at the turning point?
  4. Did reading this book in a group change how you felt about it?
  5. What will you remember about this book in a year?
  6. Is there a book you would pair with this one, and why?

Just for fun

  1. Who would you cast in the film version?
  2. What song would play over the final scene?
  3. Which fictional place from the book would you most like to visit?
  4. If you could ask the author one question, what would it be?
  5. What snack or drink does this book call for?
  6. Would this book make a good gift? For whom?

Questions for specific kinds of books

Mysteries and thrillers. When did you first suspect the answer? Was the twist fair, with clues you could have caught? Which red herring fooled you?

Memoir. What did the author choose to leave out? Do you trust their memory of events? Why do you think they wrote this book now?

Nonfiction. What's the one idea you'll repeat to someone this week? Where was the argument strongest, and where was it thin? Did the author change your mind?

Classics. What feels dated, and what feels like it could have been written this year? Why do you think it's still read? How might readers at the time have reacted?

Where to find questions for a specific book

For a question list made for your exact book, try a discussion guide library. Bookclubs.com lists more than 3,000 discussion guides and adds new ones every week, and ReadingGroupGuides.com collects guides by title and author. Many paperback editions also print a reading group guide at the back.

Frequently asked questions

How many discussion questions does a book club need?

Six to eight for a 90-minute meeting. Bring a few extra in case a question falls flat, but plan on the best two or three taking most of the time.

Should the host share the questions before the meeting?

It depends on the group. Sharing them a few days ahead helps people who like to prepare. Keeping them for the meeting makes for fresher answers. Try both and ask which the group preferred.

What if most people didn't finish the book?

Start with questions about the first half, such as first reactions and characters, and agree on a spoiler line. Then let the people who finished talk about the ending last, so nobody has to leave early to avoid spoilers.

What makes a good book club question?

It's open, so it can't be answered with yes or no. It points at something specific in the book. And people can disagree about it. "Did you like it?" ends a conversation. "Which character's choice frustrated you most?" starts one.

Start Book Club

Log your reading, get the story behind the book, and hear what friends thought at your chapter.

Open in App Store

Psst is invite-only. Sign up with code BOOKCLUB

Scan with your iPhone / Download Psst

Psst is invite-only. Sign up with code BOOKCLUB

Sources

  1. Book Club Discussion Guides
  2. ReadingGroupGuides.com